TASanalytics
TASanalytics
  • 377
  • 22 916 037
Rugby Doesn't Make Sense Anymore: Controversial Calls in Springboks vs Wales 2024
Discover the most controversial moments from the Springboks vs Wales 2024 game at the Qatar Cup. In this detailed referee analysis, we uncover the questionable decisions that left fans and commentators in disbelief.
Key Highlights:
Forward Pass Try: A clear forward pass leading to a try for South Africa that was controversially awarded.
Yellow Card Drama: Aphelele Fassi's accidental collision with Taine Plumtree resulting in a contentious yellow card.
Scrum Inconsistencies: Ox Nce's dominant scrumming penalized inconsistently by the referee.
Tackle Inconsistencies: The TMO's erratic interventions during the match.
Join us as we break down these incidents involving Referee Chris Busby, Assistant Referees Christophe Ridley and Adam Leal, and Television Match Official Mark Patton. Is rugby officiating losing its credibility? Watch our in-depth analysis and decide for yourself!
00:00 - Jesse Kriel Forward Pass
00:56 - Aphelele Fassi's Yellow Card
02:00 - Tackle Inconsistencies
04:34 - Scrum Inconsistencies
Переглядів: 34 501

Відео

The Best Defender In Rugby.
Переглядів 20 тис.4 місяці тому
Yesterday during the URC match between the Bulls vs Lions, we witnessed a masterclass on defence by Henco van Wyk. He once again showcased his World Class tackling technique and if it wasn't for him, the Lions would've gotten destroyed by the Bulls. He single handedly held them into the game with his tremendous work ethic. He made 2 try saving tackles in the game and almost made a third when he...
The Worst TMO Call In The History of Rugby
Переглядів 78 тис.4 місяці тому
How many times do we have to witness incompetent referees and TMO's ruin some of the biggest games in rugby, before something will get done? What we witnessed during the Scotland vs France Six Nations game, was daylight robery from the TMO. Scotland were 4 points behind with time expired and had to score a try to win the game. Then the most controversial part of the game happened, Sam Skinner o...
Refereeing Analysis: France vs Ireland Clash Sparks Bunker System Debate
Переглядів 7 тис.4 місяці тому
In the realm of professional rugby, the role of technology in officiating has become increasingly prominent. The advent of the Bunker System, aimed at ensuring fairness and accuracy in decision-making, has ushered in a new era of scrutiny and debate. However, as exemplified in the 2024 Six Nations match opening clash between France and Ireland, the efficacy and consistency of this system have c...
Unleashing Weapon X: Springbok's Next Prodigy - Henco van Wyk's Rise
Переглядів 94 тис.4 місяці тому
Witness the emergence of a rugby phenomenon in "Unleashing Weapon X: Springbok's Next Prodigy - Henco van Wyk's Rise". This highlight video celebrates the awe-inspiring journey of 22-year-old Henco van Wyk, a player set to redefine rugby greatness. With a playstyle echoing NFL legend Brian Dawkins, van Wyk has earned the moniker 'Weapon X', symbolizing his formidable presence on the rugby field...
From Injury to Inspiration: Siya Kolisi's Resurgence
Переглядів 6 тис.9 місяців тому
It's so good to see Siya Kolisi back on the field for the Springboks, he just makes us better in every aspect. You can see we missed him as our captain and ever since he returned from his injury, he's been amazing and is also a big reasons as to why South Africa is playing their best rugby in quite some time. It's honestly absurd as to how quickly Siya Kolisi has been able to recover as there w...
Yellow, Red, and In-Between: Refereeing Analysis of Springboks' Historic Win Over All Blacks
Переглядів 49 тис.9 місяців тому
In the tapestry of rugby history, when the Springboks and All Blacks clash, it's nothing short of epic. These are matches painted with power plays, strategic brilliance, and sheer determination. The recent showdown in south-west London will be etched in the annals as a testament to the Springboks' might and power. Setting the Scene: The Springboks and the All Blacks have given the world some of...
Canan Moodie Outside Centre Highlights
Переглядів 48 тис.10 місяців тому
I found some of my older footage on Canan Moodie back when I scouted u/20 players in the 2021 season. That's when he played for the Bulls and played outside position, which he also played back in school. As you can see in the video, he is special on attack, he just knows when to offload and has deceptive speed for someone his size. He's smooth with the ball in hand and creates space on the outs...
When World Rugby's Laws Don't Add Up | South Africa vs Wales 2023
Переглядів 88 тис.10 місяців тому
In the realm of international rugby, few matches hold as much tension and anticipation as those between rugby giants, Wales and South Africa. However, their recent clash has made headlines, not just for the sheer competitiveness exhibited on the field but for the controversial decisions that called into question the consistency of World Rugby's laws. This description aims to delve deeper into t...
Handré Pollard: The Missing Piece for the Springboks | Ultimate Highlights
Переглядів 56 тис.10 місяців тому
In the high-stakes world of rugby, a single player can sometimes be the lynchpin of a team’s success. Handré Pollard, with his stellar performances both for Leicester Tigers and the Springboks, has proven time and again why he's considered one of the best flyhalves in the world. As we venture deeper into the 2023 Rugby World Cup, the absence of Pollard due to injury has left a gaping hole in So...
Exposing World Rugby's Corruption: The Owen Farrell Red Card Controversy
Переглядів 617 тис.10 місяців тому
In the fast-paced, adrenaline-fueled world of international rugby, there are bound to be occasional missteps, accidental fouls, and honest mistakes on the field. But what happens when these inevitable instances become marred by inconsistent questionable decisions made off the pitch? In this video, we delve deep into the controversial reversal of Owen Farrell's red card and highlight the inconsi...
Funny & Hilarious Rugby Moments | Springboks Rugby
Переглядів 245 тис.10 місяців тому
I wanted to do this video last week, but didn't have time to get to it. But finally managed to complete it. It's just some of the funnier moments in the South Africa vs Argentina game. Like I said last time in my other video, there's so much that we miss by only having the broadcasters audio. It's sad because it's quite funny and interesting to hear the players and ref communicate, it brings a ...
Andre Esterhuizen: The Midfield Answer Springboks Have Been Waiting For?
Переглядів 56 тис.10 місяців тому
In the ever-evolving landscape of international rugby, timely surges in form can play pivotal roles. Amidst the concerns arising from Lukhanyo Am's injury and the wavering form of Damian de Allende, Andre Esterhuizen emerges as a beacon of hope for South Africa's midfield conundrum. In this video, we break down Esterhuizen's sterling performance against Argentina, where he once again proved his...
Lukhanyo Am's Injury: Springboks' Wake-Up Call to the Importance of a Plan B
Переглядів 47 тис.10 місяців тому
The Springboks have long been a dominant force in the world of rugby, with players that often become the stuff of legends. One such player is Lukhanyo Am, whose importance to the team cannot be overstated. Serving as the linchpin of our midfield, his unparalleled skills and leadership on the field have propelled the Springboks to numerous victories. The significance of his recent injury is hard...
Canan Moodie's EXCELLENT Performance vs Argentina | South Africa vs Argentina 2023
Переглядів 71 тис.10 місяців тому
Talk about a youngster taking his opportunities when he needed to the most. Canan Moodie had an Excellent performance vs Argentina and showed why he needs to be in the World Cup squad for 2023. He was amazing on defence and made great reads and made some dominant hits, it's rare to see a wing be as physical on defence as he is, not to mention how young he is. He's only going to get better. Then...
Unveiling What World Rugby Wants Hidden: A Deep Dive into Andrew Brace
Переглядів 96 тис.10 місяців тому
Unveiling What World Rugby Wants Hidden: A Deep Dive into Andrew Brace
Eben Etzebeth MONSTER Tackle vs All Blacks | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 48 тис.11 місяців тому
Eben Etzebeth MONSTER Tackle vs All Blacks | The Rugby Championship 2023
Funny & Hilarious Rugby Moments | South Africa vs All Blacks 2023 Rugby Championship
Переглядів 199 тис.11 місяців тому
Funny & Hilarious Rugby Moments | South Africa vs All Blacks 2023 Rugby Championship
The Two Players That Destroyed The Springboks
Переглядів 87 тис.11 місяців тому
The Two Players That Destroyed The Springboks
Cheslin Kolbe vs All Blacks | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 104 тис.11 місяців тому
Cheslin Kolbe vs All Blacks | The Rugby Championship 2023
Rugby Referee Analysis: Mathieu Raynal | Springboks vs All Blacks Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 144 тис.11 місяців тому
Rugby Referee Analysis: Mathieu Raynal | Springboks vs All Blacks Rugby Championship 2023
Duane Vermeulen Being a WORKHORSE vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 25 тис.11 місяців тому
Duane Vermeulen Being a WORKHORSE vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
André Esterhuizen EXCELLENT Performance vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 64 тис.11 місяців тому
André Esterhuizen EXCELLENT Performance vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
Jordie Barrett GREAT Performance vs Argentina | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 2,5 тис.11 місяців тому
Jordie Barrett GREAT Performance vs Argentina | The Rugby Championship 2023
Marco van Staden Performance vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
Переглядів 19 тис.11 місяців тому
Marco van Staden Performance vs Australia | The Rugby Championship 2023
Rugby Referee Analysis: Ben O'Keeffe | Springboks vs Australia 2023
Переглядів 96 тис.11 місяців тому
Rugby Referee Analysis: Ben O'Keeffe | Springboks vs Australia 2023
Kurt-Lee Arendse WORLD CLASS Performance vs Australia
Переглядів 70 тис.11 місяців тому
Kurt-Lee Arendse WORLD CLASS Performance vs Australia
Damian Markus: The Next Springbok Star?
Переглядів 37 тис.11 місяців тому
Damian Markus: The Next Springbok Star?
Handre Pollard WORLD CLASS Performance vs Bristol
Переглядів 27 тис.Рік тому
Handre Pollard WORLD CLASS Performance vs Bristol
Cheslin Kolbe Injury vs Lyon
Переглядів 42 тис.Рік тому
Cheslin Kolbe Injury vs Lyon

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @heelanbhula9056
    @heelanbhula9056 5 хвилин тому

    Missed your work, glad to see you back on UA-cam 😎

  • @Emersonion
    @Emersonion 20 хвилин тому

    I find myself watching the officials more than the game. 😢

  • @Paul-ik8fm
    @Paul-ik8fm 22 хвилини тому

    It's about doctors and lawyers now got to keep the players safe so they can't sue rugby later from their injuries

  • @ElijahMan2633
    @ElijahMan2633 33 хвилини тому

    This is all Billy Beaumonts fault.

  • @rr-vm6yd
    @rr-vm6yd 34 хвилини тому

    Are the players as confused as I am?

  • @davidevenden9294
    @davidevenden9294 36 хвилин тому

    Some very poor decisions in this game. Absolute joke.

  • @PorscheC2Boy
    @PorscheC2Boy 38 хвилин тому

    Owen does need to remember to at least try to wrap arms; I blame the coaching staff 😆 Regardless, the man is Legend, a true England warrior.

  • @man.q
    @man.q 52 хвилини тому

    The rules in rugby are becoming a joke honestly, just make it a law the every player must ware a head gear to protect them from collisions, this is so frustrating honestly 😡😡

  • @ErrolWeidemann-xn4zv
    @ErrolWeidemann-xn4zv Годину тому

    All infringements shown in this video are punishable, refs have too much power.

  • @grahammako477
    @grahammako477 Годину тому

    Yup....not interested in rugby anymore because of this. I watched some of the last world cup, first time watching rugby for a long time, man I was disappointed. 😢

  • @user-bp6qo8gw6w
    @user-bp6qo8gw6w Годину тому

    The angle of the camera is very influential. We need to look from above.

  • @ruthcarter1360
    @ruthcarter1360 Годину тому

    Referee was shocking... awful 🥴🥴

  • @chiva2507
    @chiva2507 Годину тому

    Rugby has become a very " STUPID" "sport".!! Officials, F it up,and walk away.!! High lights, Officials dumb, stupid calls.. Assistants, "flag men", interfere with on field players. They go on the pitch,shouting,and even touch players.! Refs make decisions,under assts presure,who was not in a position,to make such decisions. To much money involved in rugby.!!!

  • @isidore1883
    @isidore1883 Годину тому

    Quelque que soit, les équipes , ce sont LES arbitres, le plus gros problème actuel avec leur trop grande liberté d’interprétation des règles!!!!! A 4 paires d’yeux, ils sont incapables de voir des fautes flagrantes, ils vont tuer le rugby !! Et ce sont souvent les mêmes, j’ai déjà vu ce petit c… de Burdy saloper un match. Merci wold rugby company

  • @riyaadrhoda3990
    @riyaadrhoda3990 Годину тому

    The head collisions cause the most controvesy. Should seriously be looked at by world rugby. It cost many teams in the past and is the difference between winning and losing a game.

  • @lowiq3409
    @lowiq3409 Годину тому

    Springbok here Forward What a crap ref

  • @johnh10069
    @johnh10069 2 години тому

    Referees like to make it about them

  • @brianlawrence9732
    @brianlawrence9732 2 години тому

    This is a prime example of why I don't watch rugby anymore, RUGBY LEAGUE is the game for me now 🇳🇿👍

  • @ainsdog
    @ainsdog 2 години тому

    Rugby is not rugby anymore. It's like watching chess or netball, soft... and it's becoming American football, stop start.

  • @danie1468
    @danie1468 3 години тому

    Get rid of the lawmakers, they are destroyng our game.

  • @petruskink8971
    @petruskink8971 3 години тому

    This Unnecessary TMO destroy the game 100%😢

  • @Matthew-ud8lh
    @Matthew-ud8lh 3 години тому

    As a south african, I'm glad we won BUT this is terrible refereeing I still believe south africa would have won, but the point is that game was unfair

  • @usarugbyleagueunionfan
    @usarugbyleagueunionfan 3 години тому

    I’m going to be a Rugby League referee. I shadowed the main ref in a game yesterday. Mind you the players aren’t pros yet I can tell you this is a difficult and sometimes thankless job. There will be people yelling at me and it’s stressful. If someone thinks they can do a better job then become a referee.

  • @jinxcat8603
    @jinxcat8603 3 години тому

    Worst referee ive seen in a while

  • @hellcocktimes154
    @hellcocktimes154 4 години тому

    discovering sa wins with 16 players isnt news...accidental hhhaahahah you are insane...he clearly lifts his leg in an absolute unecessary move if his intention was to land properly...its ridiculous, this is blatant agression...and you have donkeys like you cryin about this decision.....that s what is pathetic. The ar remembered the paycheck that s all and tried to make it roll as usual for the worldclass cheats. Omg you dont even know the rules on tackles....wooooooooow.....i get it now....laws are not too complicated, you just dont understand them when they go against your interests. On all scrums you show, especially the last one, the not straigt pushin is just insanely obvious....

  • @Stormer-Europa
    @Stormer-Europa 4 години тому

    Makes perfect sense. Professional Spots balls is not just bread and circuses anymore. Much like the geo political agendas being pushed in all forms of entertainment. You would have thought by now sports events are just pi ss ups and gambling. Now it's social conditioning to having multiple cameras overhead, watching every move with a higher authority while 15 minute cities and CBDC's are being planned for you. If you survived the depop

  • @MudMud-m8v
    @MudMud-m8v 4 години тому

    Something so enjoyable about how the sad and crybaby south africans flock to TAS analytics for their fix every time a intl fixture hits. Even when they are winning they are whining and moaning about it. Please know the rest of the world laughs at you. For every good springbok theres 100'000 soft brehs crying into their pints over the ref. laughing stock. Rassie looks like mrs doubtfire and you are all juicing boys at u16s and you well know it. Most dimwitted rugby community on the face of the earth full stop. Ciao.

  • @gertjoubert7221
    @gertjoubert7221 5 годин тому

    We will have this forever. It will never stop. There is one ref. He can not keep his eye on the ball all the time. He also have to look behind him at times during fast play to look where the other players are in case of off side positions when a player suddenly kicks the ball forward. The ref do not have a replay and he is not always in line with the ball carriers. Many times on criticle time players also can block his view. Later on the camera shows everything with replay and replay and replay. What a mess with new technology

  • @markbruce7674
    @markbruce7674 5 годин тому

    Sometimes its not worth watching anymore...

  • @josephvanwyk2088
    @josephvanwyk2088 5 годин тому

    Utter shit ref. People are getting sick and tired of world rugby inexperienced choices. Saying this as a South African - Yes, that was a forward pass try.

  • @theflaver
    @theflaver 5 годин тому

    bring back Nigel!

  • @patriciaadendorf7899
    @patriciaadendorf7899 5 годин тому

    Just going on and on really now that shows clearly a forward pass look what happens at the World cup how can u be proud of a team who makes such mistakes and the ref don't see the mistakes really something must be done to the TMO not a pleasure to watch rugby anymore

  • @systerpietersen2778
    @systerpietersen2778 6 годин тому

    this ref also want attention

  • @brianhartley4160
    @brianhartley4160 6 годин тому

    Soon rugby will become a non contact sport.It's becoming a sick joke.

    • @Ollies2CentsWardill
      @Ollies2CentsWardill 3 години тому

      It's as physical as ever, if not more so. Modern players are huge, extraordinarily fit and collisions are spectacular. What would be the advantage of allowing them to bash each others heads and twist knees?

  • @charliestevens373
    @charliestevens373 6 годин тому

    It doesn't make sense to one eyed idiots how analyse every slo mo

  • @georgefrederikoosthuizen891
    @georgefrederikoosthuizen891 6 годин тому

    Do basically WR F^$#@$t!!!,the sport in so that it isnt made worth watching anymore ,and referees cant intripitrate all laws consistently anymore,so better go fishing atleast u and the fish 1 on 1 not 12,13,14 vs 15 men every match and bias refereeing...

  • @THEMRblackboy7thst
    @THEMRblackboy7thst 6 годин тому

    im a huge SA fan but i have to say it as it is, that 3rd try was from a forward pass, like by a mile. I called it at the exact moment.

  • @johangrove7342
    @johangrove7342 6 годин тому

    I'm a bok fan but this ref needs to be fined for ruining the match. He shouldn't refferee anymore

  • @elduderino3236
    @elduderino3236 6 годин тому

    Paddy O'Brian 2.0

  • @sassyboy4619
    @sassyboy4619 6 годин тому

    Thank goodness you back thought something bad happened to you

  • @deanowarrior
    @deanowarrior 6 годин тому

    Should never be allowed to tmo again. Hopeless or corrupt it doesn't really matter . Forward beyond any argument.

  • @eddiediesel9035
    @eddiediesel9035 6 годин тому

    I see forward passes and shepherding going unnoticed by the ref officials all the time now in rugby and rugby league. It's a joke.

  • @fitzerelli1
    @fitzerelli1 7 годин тому

    I've seen a lot of forward passes in recent times. Big teams seem to be allowed to do it.

  • @ricardocarvalho1290
    @ricardocarvalho1290 7 годин тому

    100% forward pass but Wales would still lose.

  • @deejay1313
    @deejay1313 7 годин тому

    The TMO should be there to assist the referees and touch judges in arriving at decisions; he should not have the ability to be an automatic second "on-field" ref. The TMO should sit with a representative from either side, and they should have the opportunity to review and assist in decisions immediately upon request. Rugby is rough, tough and not always fair (like life), but it should be left to the on-field referees to perform their functions without interference. If this goes much further, AI may well be used to referee future games.

  • @354sd
    @354sd 7 годин тому

    Bring back rucking, hooking and backward passing . Simples.

  • @GerryComninos-sc2pb
    @GerryComninos-sc2pb 7 годин тому

    I gave up watching halfway through the game. Idiot ref the game for both teams. TMO is a twit as well. Typical ambush of Boks. If you can’t beat them confuse them. Most unpleasant game.

  • @colin4685
    @colin4685 7 годин тому

    Dirty SA cheats as usual

  • @clydehaskell2975
    @clydehaskell2975 7 годин тому

    IMO, World Rugby are destroying the game. When the game needs 6 people ( 1 ref, 2 touch judges and 3 in the "bunker") to police the game, anyone with a brain in their head could figure out that the game is too complicated.

  • @NoName-hg6cc
    @NoName-hg6cc 7 годин тому

    The laws are too complicated, they are just too open for interpretation by biased/lazy ref